DELAWARE — A dispute over 583 provisional ballots has delayed the official canvass and an automatic recount in Delaware County’s closely-contested commissioner race.
The Delaware County Board of Elections met Tuesday to review provisional ballots from the Nov. 3 election, voting to count 1,400 of them.
Of those, 526 were cast at the board of elections office on Election Day, while 874 came from voters who moved within Delaware County but had not updated their voter registrations to reflect their new precincts by the 30-day deadline prior to the election.
Those ballots, along with 42 military, overseas and absentee ballots, have been added to the interim canvass. Republican Renee Vaughan still holds the majority vote over Democrat Ryan Grissinger, but by an even slimmer margin.
Vaughan previously had the majority by 514 votes, according to final unofficial results from election night. That margin has now narrowed to 423 votes, making an automatic recount still necessary.
However, the canvass remains incomplete after board members deadlocked over whether to count another 583 provisional ballots — more than the current margin separating the candidates.
Those ballots came from voters who moved to Delaware County from another Ohio county but did not update their voter registration before the deadline, and voted at neighborhood precinct polling locations.
Republican board members Steve Cuckler and Jessica Miller voted against counting the ballots, while Democratic members Ed Helvey and Peg Watkins voted in favor.
The tie vote resulted in the board sending the matter to Secretary of State Frank LaRose for guidance and a final decision.
The incomplete canvass delays the official recount, initially scheduled for next week.
Other Ohio boards of elections have faced similar disputes over provisional ballots cast by voters who moved between counties, with law firms urging some boards not to count them.
In Delaware County, Columbus-based law firm Bricker Graydon Wyatt LLP has weighed in on the issue. Attorney Ryan L. Richardson attended Tuesday’s meeting representing Vaughan, who was also present.
Why the 583 ballots are in dispute
A provisional ballot serves as a safeguard for voters whose identity or eligibility cannot immediately be verified, allowing them to cast a ballot that will be counted once their eligibility is confirmed, according to the Ohio Secretary of State’s website.
Voters may be required to cast provisional ballots for several reasons, including lacking proper identification, changing their names without documentation, having signatures that do not match election records or moving without updating their voter registrations before the deadline.
At the center of Delaware County’s dispute is where voters who moved from another Ohio county were permitted to cast those ballots.
Vaughan’s attorney argued that voters who moved into Delaware County without updating their registrations before the deadline were required to cast provisional ballots at the Board of Elections office or a board-designated location, rather than at their neighborhood polling places.
All 583 disputed ballots were cast at neighborhood polling locations.
In a letter sent to the board Monday and obtained by Delaware Source, Christopher Slagle, a partner at Columbus-based law firm Bricker Graydon Wyatt LLP, urged board members to reject those ballots.
“We respectfully ask request the board to reject that category of provisional ballots because Ohio law makes the location of casting an express condition of a county-to-county mover’s eligibility to vote in the election,” Slagle wrote.
Slagle cited Ohio Revised Code 3503.16(C), arguing that the location where a provisional ballot is cast is a condition of eligibility for voters who move between counties.
He also requested that the board set the ballots aside for further review by Secretary of State Frank LaRose if members could not agree to reject them.
That’s ultimately what happened.
Democrats argue votes should not be disenfranchised
Board Chair Ed Helvey challenged that interpretation, pointing to Ohio Revised Code 3505.181, specifically sections (B)(3) and (B)(4).
Those provisions address the process for transferring provisional ballots and voter information to election officials for verification.
The law states: “If the appropriate local election official to whom the ballot or voter or address information is transmitted under division (B)(3) of this section determines that the individual is eligible to vote, the individual’s provisional ballot shall be counted as a vote in that election.”
“So, it seems to be in direct conflict to what you’re saying,” Helvey told Vaughan’s attorney, Ryan Richardson.
However, Cuckler pointed out that another provision Helvey cited, section (A)(6), specifically addresses voters who change both their names and counties, raising questions about whether it applies to all 583 ballots.
Richardson agreed, arguing that the provision addresses a different scenario than the one before the board.
Watkins also pointed to the secretary of state’s handbook for boards of elections, which she said indicates provisional voting may take place on Election Day at the Board of Elections office or a voter’s correct polling location.
“I’m thinking that if this is how the secretary of state interpreted that, I would go with what they have to say,” Watkins said.
“Even if you were to interpret the directive as allowing for that, a directive cannot trump the plain language of a statute,” Richardson responded.
Helvey also noted that while provisional voters were once required to visit the Delaware County Board of Elections office, the county has allowed them to cast provisional ballots at polling locations in more recent years.
He questioned whether it would be fair to reject ballots cast by voters who followed instructions from election workers.
“To say now that we’ve done things wrong for a number of years and have counted votes that were improper is one thing,” Helvey said. “But the other thing, too, is I don’t want to have to spin on our heads and say, we’re gonna disenfranchise people that did exactly what they were told to do.”
The board is scheduled to meet again at 4 p.m. Monday to continue the official canvass, with LaRose’s guidance expected to help resolve the dispute over the remaining 583 provisional ballots.
