Rendering of 120 E. Olentangy St. shopping center created by Equity Development and provided by the city of Powell.

POWELL — A proposed shopping center on East Olentangy Street has already been rejected twice. Now, despite another round of design changes, city staff are recommending Powell reject it again.

The city’s Planning and Zoning Commission reviewed revised plans Wednesday for the proposed 21,600-square-foot commercial development at 120 E. Olentangy St., but stopped short of making a decision.

Instead of approving or denying the plan as the commission typically does, Chairman David Lester said the commission would issue a written decision to the developer by Dec. 4.

That decision does not need to be presented at a formal meeting, Lester said.

However, City Planning Manager Claudia Husak’s recommendation to the commission was to deny the plans again because they do not meet three out of the four final development plan criteria.

The commission has already denied plans for the site twice, first in May to allow for some design changes, including adding a breezeway between some of the tenant spaces.

Commissioners rejected the proposal again in September amid lingering concerns from city staff about the building’s shape, architectural design and whether a single-story commercial development is appropriate along a prominent corridor where staff favors mixed-use development.

The city also received 20 public comments opposing the project, with residents raising concerns about traffic, the building’s design and size, and business turnover at nearby shopping centers.

The latest revisions include changes to the building’s roofline, replacing the previously flat roof with a combination of flat and peaked sections.

The proposed plans meet stormwater management requirements, parking requirements and over-exceeds landscaping buffer requirements by 10 feet to meet residents’ concerns.

Staff recommends disapproval

Husak noted in a staff report the proposal strives to be consistent with downtown design guidelines, noting the building’s entrances face the sidewalk, have two outdoor patios on both sides that are attractive for restaurants, parking is interconnected and the architectural detailing “contributes to the city’s character.”

She determined the proposal meets one of the four criteria required for final development plan approval: compliance with applicable zoning code standards.

However, she recommended denial because the project fails to meet the remaining three criteria:

  • Consistency with area plans and design guidelines: Husak described the proposal as “one-dimensional” and said it falls short of supporting downtown business growth through a more diverse, mixed-use development approach.
  • Impact on the surrounding area: Husak said the single-story development does not align with the city’s plans to encourage mixed-use development. Equity Development President Patrick Wathen previously told commissioners that adding apartments above the commercial spaces would not be financially feasible.
  • Compatibility with surrounding development: Husak expressed concern that approving a single-story shopping center could make it more difficult for future developments to meet the city’s long-term goals while remaining compatible with neighboring properties.

“Future developments over one-story would further standout when viewed from East Olentangy Street,” Husak wrote in her staff report.

Developer challenges recommendation

Aaron Underhill, a zoning law attorney representing the developer, said it was unfair Equity only received an architectural update that night with no prior comments provided.

He also challenged Husak’s grounds for denial, saying if the commercial building is a permitted use in the zoning district and the site is appropriate for that use, then it should be permitted.

“Termination on this criterion is based on a market analysis that is not a part of codified ordinances and is a reference to the comprehensive plan…which is a recommending policy document, not the law,” Underhill said.

Sarah Freiheit, also representing Equity, said the developer has made numerous changes in response to feedback throughout the review process. She described the latest architectural concerns as minor issues that could be easily addressed.

Michelle Williams, who provided architectural feedback on behalf of the city, agreed that the design remained one-dimensional and recommended incorporating more stonework.

Freiheit also said the development concepts already have interest from tenants, including a fitness center, a smoothie restaurant and a salon.

Revised plans seem to have more support

Powell resident Scott Scharlach spoke during public comment, identifying himself as a prospective tenant interested in opening a smoothie and protein bowl restaurant in the shopping center.

Scharlach said the restaurant would operate seven days a week, from 8 a.m. to 8 p.m.

“If I can’t get something done here soon, I will have to take my business to probably Dublin or Worthinton or Westerville because we need to move forward,” he said.

“For the record, a lot of Powell residents do want this development to go through, and I’m very much looking forward to investing our future and our family business here in this location.”

Resident John Patterson also spoke, complimenting the developers on the architectural changes and said “it’s a good project,” only offering minor feedback about the design.

Commission member Shaun Simpson said he still prefers a concept that features two stories, but the revised designs are “significantly better.”

“I think it’s great what you’ve done, you’ve listened to the community, and I want to commend you on that,” Commission Member Ross Irvine said.

Once the commission issues its decision Dec. 4, that will be the final approval in the process because the new zoning code designates the commission as the deciding body, not city council.

General assignment reporter at Delaware Source, writing about education, government and everything in between. Ohio University alumna, outdoor enthusiast and cat lover. Share your story ideas or tips with...