A "vote here" sign at the Fraternal Order of the Eagles polling location in the Nov. 3 general election. Credit: Taylor Henninger

DELAWARE — Secretary of State Frank LaRose says he cannot be the tie-breaker in a split decision among the Delaware County Board of Elections on whether to count 583 provisional ballot votes.

In a letter sent to the BOE obtained by Delaware Source, LaRose said the board’s tie vote that resulted in a request for LaRose to issue a decision on the matter is not a proper tie-vote request.

“There are limits to what questions or issues are proper for review by my office,” LaRose said. “Some motions require the consensus of at least three board members to pass. A 2-2 tie on such a motion means that a motion fails by operation of law.

“A disagreement about whether to count a provisional ballot is one such motion and therefore not a proper matter for review as a tie vote by my office.”

Further, LaRose wrote because “three of the members do not agree,” the ballots shall not be counted under R.C. 3505.27 “as a matter of law.”

Therefore, LaRose did not issue a substantive decision.

However, he did recommend board members continue conversations with counsel, which is Delaware County Prosecutor Melissa Schiffel.

He also encouraged the board to inform counsel of a “pending expedited matter in the Ohio Supreme Court,” an ongoing case involving the State of Ohio ex rel. Edward L. Schimmel v. Lucas County Board of Elections, et al., Case No. 2026-1574.

“That case involves the underlying question at issue here: whether a county board of elections should count provisional ballots cast by voters who moved to the county, failed to update their voter registration, and cast provisional ballots at polling locations rather than at the board of elections,” LaRose wrote.

On Monday, the board will meet again to discuss the matter further.

If the decision is another tie vote, based on LaRose’s comments, the board will not count the provisional ballot votes.

Background on the matter

A provisional ballot serves as a safeguard for voters whose identity or eligibility cannot immediately be verified, allowing them to cast a ballot that will be counted once their eligibility is confirmed, according to the Ohio Secretary of State’s website.

Voters may be required to cast provisional ballots for several reasons, including lacking proper identification, changing their names without documentation, having signatures that do not match election records or moving without updating their voter registrations before the deadline.

The Delaware County Board of Elections met Tuesday to review provisional ballots from the Nov. 3 election, voting to count 1,400 of them.

Of those, 526 were cast at the board of elections office on Election Day, while 874 came from voters who moved within Delaware County but had not updated their voter registrations to reflect their new precincts by the 30-day deadline prior to the election. 

Those ballots, along with 42 military, overseas and absentee ballots, have been added to the interim canvass.

However, the canvass remains incomplete after board members deadlocked over whether to count another 583 provisional ballots, which came from voters who moved to Delaware County from another Ohio county but did not update their voter registration before the deadline and voted at neighborhood precinct polling locations.

Republican election board members Steve Cuckler and Jessica Miller voted against counting the ballots, while Democratic members Ed Helvey and Peg Watkins voted in favor.

Those ballots could sway the outcome of a county commissioner race between Republican Renee Vaughan and Democrat Ryan Grissinger.

Vaughn still held the majority vote over but Grissinger after the 1,400 provisional votes were counted, but by an even slimmer margin.

Vaughan previously had the majority by 514 votes, according to final, unofficial results from election night. That margin has now narrowed to 423 votes, meaning an automatic recount is still necessary.

Vaughan’s attorney argued at the meeting that the 583 voters who moved into Delaware County without updating their registrations before the deadline were required to cast provisional ballots at the Board of Elections office or a board-designated location, rather than at their neighborhood polling places.

But Watkins interpreted a directive provided by LaRose’s office to mean provisional voting may take place on Election Day at the Board of Elections office or a voter’s correct polling location.

“I’m thinking that if this is how the secretary of state interpreted that, I would go with what they have to say,” Watkins said.

Helvey noted that while provisional voters were once required to visit the Delaware County Board of Elections office, the county has allowed them to cast provisional ballots at polling locations in more recent years.

At the meeting Tuesday, Helvey questioned whether it would be fair to reject ballots cast by voters who followed instructions from election workers.

“To say now that we’ve done things wrong for a number of years and have counted votes that were improper is one thing,” Helvey said. “But the other thing, too, is I don’t want to have to spin on our heads and say, ‘We’re gonna disenfranchise people that did exactly what they were told to do.’”

The board will make a final decision Monday on whether to count the provisional ballot votes.

General assignment reporter at Delaware Source, writing about education, government and everything in between. Ohio University alumna, outdoor enthusiast and cat lover. Share your story ideas or tips with...